Jun 13, Craig rated it it was ok First, the negatives: Actual information about Ida is sorely lacking, and what little there is seems to be designed mainly to exaggerate the importance of this find, with a common tactic being to denigrate other fossil specimens First, the negatives: Actual information about Ida is sorely lacking, and what little there is seems to be designed mainly to exaggerate the importance of this find, with a common tactic being to denigrate other fossil specimens in order to artificially increase the seeming importance of this one. Lucy is criticized for not being as obviously on the human line when the exact opposite is true, and "missing links" in general are made to seem extremely rare in order to emphasize how amazing this find is.
Brian Ferguson From the Reviews: Colin Tudge admits that "this is indeed only a hypothesis" and that evidence is scant. I would go further and say that the theory is baseless and not in the least Darwinian.
Brian Ferguson, Natural History Please note that these ratings solely represent the complete review's biased interpretation and subjective opinion of the actual reviews and do not claim to accurately reflect or represent the views of the reviewers.
Similarly the illustrative quotes chosen here are merely those the complete review subjectively believes represent the tenor and judgment of the review as a whole.
We acknowledge and remind and warn you that they may, in fact, be entirely unrepresentative of the actual reviews by any other measure. Each title in the Darwin Today series aims to be, according to the editors, "an authoritative pocket introduction to the Darwinian ideas that are setting today's intellectual agenda.
Refer to the links for further information.
Colin Tudge's small book barely mentions Darwin, though the conclusions he reaches are, indeed, shaped by Darwinism. Tudge challenges the widely held belief that farming first began in the Middle East about 10, years ago.
He sets out here to prove that proto-farming actually began much earlier -- about 40, years ago. His interpretation of how farming really began is quite convincing -- in part because he acknowledges a gradual transition to an agricultural lifestyle, with the proto-farmers not solely depending on agriculture for their food.
Tudge paints an interesting Darwinian picture of the forces that moved man towards agriculture as opposed to trying to survive merely on whatever was at handand he demonstrates that it was possible for this transition to take place earlier than is generally thought.
The benefits of agriculture were great, giving man a great deal of control over his food supply -- but, as Tudge points out, the costs were also high. A vicious circle of rapidly growing populations because of the steady food supply and the resulting need to cultivate more land made for an arduous life.
Similarly, once the move towards dependency on agriculture had been made there was no turning back. Of interest is also how Tudge shows the devastating impact human migration had on native wildlife, especially in the Americas and Australia, with many genera wiped out over a short period of time.
This, too, illustrates part of his argument: Tudge's brief account is thoughtful and entertaining, and he makes a good case for his theory.Colin Tudge’s essay, in which he rejects ‘‘rule by expert’’, provides a refreshingly different perspective, taking a mature view of the relevance of religious belief and its place in moral history, and proposing that we implement technol-ogy inline with a pre-conceived view of what kind.
Jan 01, · This is a short monograph (50 pages) that synopsizes Colin Tudge's argument that pre-Neolithic Revolution humans (and, indeed, hominids in general) have been modifying their environment for hundreds of millennia, and this includes "farming," of which Tudge identifies three types/5.
Colin Tudge was educated at Dulwich College, ; and read zoology at Peterhouse, Cambridge, Since he has worked on journals such as World Medicine, New Scientist and Pan, the newspaper of the World Food Conference held in Rome, /5.
The zoologist Colin Tudge () observes that This essay may be found on page of the printed volume. Works Cited Permanent Link to this Essay. About this Site; Rights; close.
Hollindale, Peter. "Nature." Keywords for Children's Literature. Eds. Philip Nel and Lissa Paul. New York: New York University Press, Buy The Variety of Life: A Survey and a Celebration of All the Creatures That Have Ever Lived by Colin Tudge () by Colin Tudge (ISBN:) from Amazon's Book Store.
Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible timberdesignmag.coms: Uncovering Our Earliest Ancestors: The Link is about the discovery of Ida.
Ida is the alleged primate fossil that could link the two groups together. This fossil, forty-seven million years old, is the oldest and most complete primate yet to be found.
Written by Colin Tudge, this non-fiction book.